Spindle trips GFCI outlets

I just found out that the Spindle will not work with GFCI recepticles, unfortunatly, all of my outside and shop recepticles are GFCI. This is required by code. Has anyone found a fix for this issue short of running a non-GFCI circut to my shop?

Thanks

Tim

Hi Tim,

I had the same issue with my Altmill spindle. The issue is the VFD drive that varies the frequency of power to the motor to control the speed. I ran a dedicated 20 amp, non GFCI circuit and problem was solved. When I ran it, I assumed that I would have to replace that outlet with a GFCI outlet when we sell the house or get an inspection by the city. If you don’t want the hassle, I’d check out the Autospin T1 router. I’m sure Sienci can answer if it will run on a GFCI circuit.

Best of luck, perhaps other users have found work arounds. I’ll be watching the thread!

Doug

You might be able to replace the outlets for normal ones, and run the shop on a rccb 30ma circuit breaker instead.

I have had no issues with a Siemens 20A CAFCI/GFCI breaker protecting the outlet that the 1.5kW Sienci spindle and VFD is connected to.

Thanks for your suggestion, it helped!

Tim

Tim,

been reading into this a bit as I know it’s a common issue. The new Eaton BRN220GFCS breakers are apparently now being made VFD friendly. They are digital and can disregard high frequency leakage. Says it will work with VFD on the home depot website .

I do not believe gfci receptacles though have the ability to disregard high frequency leakage yet so it would need to be a breaker at the pannel. My current set up is the digital breaker at the pannel and a normal receptacle in garage.

Machine came in today so I’m hoping it’s gonna work. If not I’m getting rid of the gfci.

Can confirm, spindle is doing its break in just fine, no tripping.

Last test would be under load and it’s prolly good

Make sure you have nothing else on the same circuit. A dedicated circuit is best. I have GFCI outlets with no issue, but they are 20amps.

Hi Tim,

For you and anyone else looking for information on this topic, I wanted to share the remainder of my experience.

I spent months frustrated after learning that VFDs generally don’t play well with standard GFCI breakers. With electrical code requiring GFCI protection in garages, there aren’t many options for getting around the issue.

There also seems to be very little useful information out there. Most discussions just end with people saying that GFCIs and VFDs don’t work together, or people that have older garages where the electrical is grandfathered in do they just have a standard breaker, suggestions to just swap the breaker out for a non gfci etc. Even the electricians I spoke with weren’t particularly familiar with newer GFCI breakers that may be more compatible with VFDs, just looked at me cross eyed when I asked they how old the breaker is they were going to install in my electrical cabinet . I believe at least with the Eaton 220 20amp anything after 2023 has the newer tech, but it’s not exactly something they put on the box.

To be clear, I still don’t know whether an older Anaolog GFCI breaker would have worked with my setup, since I never had one to test. All I know is that I’ve repeatedly been told they don’t work well with VFDs. At the same time, I’ve come across people who have had no issues running them together, while others experience constant tripping. The conflicting information makes the whole subject incredibly confusing, especially when you’re trying to figure out what will actually work before spending the money.

It was especially frustrating having already invested so much money into the CNC machine and electrical installation without knowing whether the spindle would even work properly.

Anyway, I’m happy to report that, at least in my specific setup described earlier in this thread, my spindle works perfectly fine with the newer Eaton 20-amp digital GFCI breaker. Now you can tell it’s digital because the breaker has an indicator light on it that will flash from different faults if it has any. This breaker has special sensing in it that allows it to disregard some types of leaking voltage (the kind that a VFD creates) It’s prolly not a catch all, if the leaking gets too bad it may still trip but I haven’t had this happen yet.

I’ve now put approximately 15 hours of actual cutting time on the machine under load, and the breaker hasn’t tripped once. Everything is working exactly as it should.

I wanted to share this because I know how difficult it was to find a real-world example of someone successfully running a VFD spindle on a GFCI-protected circuit. Hopefully, this helps someone else who’s dealing with the same uncertainty.

3 Likes

Didn’t realize that was called “digital” but that is the same as the Siemens plug-on-neutral GFCI/AFCI breaker I am using that also works.